[mailing] [mb-style] 'Op. XX No. YY' or 'Op. XX, No. YY'

[Marco Sola]

Il Monday, November 27, 2006 6:47 PM
mll <webmll at laposte.net> ha scritto:

> the case where a  track is numbered 'Op. XX No. YY', like 'Mazurka in B 
> major, Op. 63
> No. 1' (example at 
> http://musicbrainz.org/track/576a7830-8240-4611-804c-256ee0e4bce3.html).
>
> I can see to ways of expressing it:
> 1) 'Mazurka in B major, Op. 63 No. 1'
> OR
> 2) 'Mazurka in B major, Op. 63, No. 1'

(Thanks for this.)

To me that I'm against all commas in TrackTitile 1 is of course preferable.

Just be aware that there's a lot of  'Mazurka in B major, Op. 63/1' around: 
are they allowed? should they be changed? are they simply not part of this 
rule that is only about commas?

> And if we come to an agreement, should we take out the heavy gun of a
> RFV? This is an addition to the rule, not a change per se.

I can't see the difference: an addition is a change.

Ciao

MArco (ClutchEr2)