[mb-style] MultipleTitleStyle with similar classical pieces
Leiv Hellebø
leivhe at broadpark.no
Wed Nov 29 13:19:02 UTC 2006
MLL wrote:
>
>> >Any good reasons to stray further from original release title other
>> >than your personal preference?
>
> None. But
> 1. I remember MB decided that we definitely make up our own classical
> release titles when the original is inaccurate / uncomplete
"when it is inaccurate / uncomplete", a good guideline. This is far from
a carte blanche for enforcing a common pattern on accurate and complete
titles. My point is that we should keep as close as possible to the
originals.
> 2. we should have a common guideline, be it with or without ampersands
see above. Let the original decide whether or not to use ampersands.
> 3. my preference is without ampersand, so that the rule is simpler to
> remember (always commas be there 2, 3 or more symphonies) and apply
> (correcting titles where 1 or more numbers lack).
see above. Let the original decide whether or not to use ampersands, and
add the missing parts according to the style of the original release.
>
> I'd say it's not illogical, but gramatically incorrect. Logic is why I
> support not according to the plural.
>
I guess your brains [including mare better at interpolating the "and"
when reading "Symphonies No. 1, No. 4" than mine is :)
> Even on the field of grammar, you could escape gracefully by saying the
> comma symbolises a repetition of the previous term, ie:
> 'Symphony No. 91, No. 92' = 'Symphony No. 91, Symphony No. 92' :)
It is hardly graceful to distort/modify common comma usage.
>
>>
>>
>> >2) As for searching, I guess what you really need is software which
>> >provides regular expression searches. Searching for "Symph.* 4"
>> >would return both English and German releases.
>>
>> Agreed.
>
> I was speaking of MB's website search. No regexp searchs as of today
Yes, there is. Try the release search for "volume .* monteverdi".
> AFAIK. Moreover, regexp search is not non-geek friendly.
>
Non-geeks have a hard time anyway on this one.
leivhe
More information about the Musicbrainz-style
mailing list