[mb-style] RFC[?]: Update Classical Style Guide to account for'recital discs']

Dave Smey autodave at davesmey.com
Mon Oct 2 21:35:50 UTC 2006


On Mon, October 2, 2006 5:27 pm, Dave Smey said:

>>
>> Long time ago I did a test conversion (which btw I did not reverted) and
> asked for comments/veto. At that time no one agreed. A longest debate
> and examples are on CSGD.
>>
>> Release is here:
>> http://musicbrainz.org/release/ab41dfc4-faab-4e1c-ac7e-c07752dd3395.html
>>
> I can't really see the context very well, but it appears that the concern
> was that this was before it was possible to have a seperate ReleaseArtist
> and various TrackArtists?
>
No, I am wrong. Sorry.  How do I find the old debate? (What is CSGD?)

I see a fair amount of releases like this in MB, and just discussed moving
my own edits to this format a month or two ago on mb-users.  At that time
no one objected.

Cheers,
-D




More information about the Musicbrainz-style mailing list