[mb-style] RFC: english capitalization of shortened words beginingwith a single quote

Mangled viapanda at gmail.com
Sat Sep 2 16:17:33 UTC 2006


2006/9/1, Steve Wyles <steve at inhouse.co.uk>:
> As they are guidelines instead of strict rules, I would use the word
> 'should' instead of 'must'.

Sure.


2006/9/2, Michelle . <jack_fairy at hotmail.com>:
> - capitalised if the word it stands for would normally be capitalised
> - not capitalised if the word it stands for would normally not be
> capitalised

Apparently, most people felt the "aphesis" should be lowercased
(except when at the beginning of the sentence)...
While of course it is not too late to discuss this again (and as
stated I myself don't have a preference), I think it will take a
stronger argument than "more consistent with other guidelines" to have
this accepted.

> Also, a lot of titles in the database are grammatically incorrect, with
> missing abbreviation apostrophes (eg. Round instead of 'Round). This version
> of the guideline would keep the capitalisation consistent across these
> versions:

True.


- Olivier



More information about the Musicbrainz-style mailing list