[mb-style] RFC: Change BoxSetNameStyle

Chris B chris at whenironsattack.com
Tue Mar 25 10:02:24 UTC 2008


On 25/03/2008, Leiv Hellebo <leiv.hellebo at gmail.com> wrote:
> Chris B wrote:
>  > i mean, if one CD is mastered by X and one by Y then you can't merge
>  > them. the ARs are different, the PUIDs are different, the CD-IDs* will
>  > be different, etc. vote No to such merges with confidence!
>
>
> Here's a recent edit merging two releases. (I added the rerelease with a
>  RemasteredAR, as it was remastered, see annotation.)
>
>  http://musicbrainz.org/show/edit/?editid=8450199
>
>  Now, there're no PUIDs and ARs specific to only one here, yet, but
>  someone might change that.
>
>  Are you saying you would vote no to this merge?

i probably wouldn't vote no as there doesn't seem to be any info being
lost apart from the 'is remastered...' AR. i would abstain :)



More information about the Musicbrainz-style mailing list