[mb-style] RFV: Supporting Release Relationship Type

Kuno Woudt kuno at frob.nl
Fri Apr 2 05:56:22 UTC 2010


Excerpts from Brian Schweitzer's message of Fri Apr 02 04:56:09 +0200 2010:
> This is not an April 1 email.  :D
> 
> No objection having been heard, and the RFC period having expired on 4/1,
> this proposal is now at RFV.  I'll split the NGS version's documentation off
> to RFC-52a, so this would just be for the release-release AR+doc and the NGS
> RG-RG AR w/o finalized doc.

I haven't been as involved in mb-style in recent months due to some
other things stealing my time.  So, my apologies for giving feedback
this late.

Under the "Guidelines" heading you mention:

      Compilations and soundtracks cannot be supporting releases,
      though they can be supported by another release.

Why not?

This is a compilation released in support of a new album:
http://www.discogs.com/release/1855730

I don't have an example for soundtracks, and agree that would be
unlikely, but I see no reason to specifically exclude them in the
guideline.  If they don't exist no one will try to add them as such.

-- kuno / warp.



More information about the Musicbrainz-style mailing list