[mb-users] Tagging a Continuous Mix CD

Lukáš Lalinský lalinsky at gmail.com
Thu Jul 20 07:30:06 UTC 2006


Arturus Magi wrote:
> However, this does bring up something else: any ideas on what to do
> with PUIDs derived from album-at-once recordings like this?  Attaching
> them to some random track is obviously problematic, but they can't be
> attached to the releases themselves.

The tracks are available for download also separately. I don't see any problem
with PUIDs. The all-in-one format is only an additional format for people who
don't want to download the files one by one.

Anyway, I personally think we should follow the physical structure *only* for CD
releases. Since MB already allows DVDs, and they come as all-in-one track in 99%
cases, we already have different rules for different mediums.



More information about the MusicBrainz-users mailing list