[mb-users] Adding Disc ID from CUE Sheet?

[Age Bosma]

Andy Hawkins wrote:
> Hi,
> 
> In article <99aa47730701072029s5040f19cya888b01803be9d38 at mail.gmail.com>,
>            Arturus Magi<sailorleo at gmail.com> wrote:
>> The only legitimate use I can think of is the mentioned example of album
>> in a single file burns (and we still don't want to submit those DiscIDs...
>> only use them for matching against existing IDs to tag the file or add the
>> CD to a local database).
> 
> Why would you not want them submitted? I check after ripping that the disc
> ID calculated from my FLAC file matches that calculated by the MusicBrainz
> library direct from the CD. As long as they match, then there's no problem,
> surely?
> 

In your case they might match but that doesn't mean everyone else will 
be as careful as you. You are able to check against the original, others 
might not. If they are able to check against the original disc, what's 
the point in using the CUE sheet to calculate and submit disc ids in the 
first place?
It would be a nice feature if you could calculate the disc id based on 
the CUE sheet to retrieve info from MusicBrainz, but submitting disc ids 
based on CUE sheet info will only cause more trouble.

Yours,

Age