[mb-users] Linking Disc IDs to Release events

Bernd Kuemmerlen bkuemmer at gmx.net
Fri Sep 7 09:43:32 UTC 2007


Kuno Woudt wrote:
> I think in most cases where the disc id differs, it would warrant a
> seperate entry in the database.  mastering ARs and whatnot will likely
> be different, etc...

At the moment it seems to be the most reasonable way to duplicate the
entries, but this seems to be against the general consensus that there
should be no duplication if there are no "significant" differences. Edits
like this might get quite some opposition. After all, the Disc TOCs of the
1997 and 2007 editions are pretty close, and what about the 7 Disc IDs
attached to
http://musicbrainz.org/release/1f715142-a0ef-48c8-9e72-c402e5bad13f.html ?
We certainly don't want 7 different DB entries in this case.

Cheers
Bernd




More information about the MusicBrainz-users mailing list