[mb-users] feedback on separate release for remastered disc.
George Hartzell
hartzell at alerce.com
Wed Apr 30 16:36:19 UTC 2008
I added a new release for the 1993 remastered release of Jesus Christ
Superstar, reasoning that since the audio is different, the Amazon
ASIN is different, the cover art is different and the catalog info is
different it justified a separate entry. Without a separate entry I
get incorrect cover art when I tag the discs with Picard. With the
separate entry the right thing happens.
I received a comment on my addition
http://musicbrainz.org/show/edit/index.html?editid=8700420
stating that I should have added it to the 1970 release.
To my mind they're not the same thing. The track lengths are only
subtly different but the audio's been redone.
I'm new at this and I'd appreciate some feedback about how the
community handles remastered releases.
Thanks!
g.
More information about the MusicBrainz-users
mailing list