[mb-users] Group had to change there name - two artist entries?

Olivier viapanda at gmail.com
Tue Feb 26 17:47:41 UTC 2008


2008/2/26, Alexander Kiel <alexanderkiel at gmx.net>:
>  Ok I'm hunting for other examples. Perhaps we should document the
>  Alias/two artist issue better and with help of consistent examples.
>

That's the purpose of
http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/SameArtistWithDifferentNames which hasn't
triggered comments during RFC, and has been in RFV for a couple of
days now.

If you feel it could use more flesh in places, or additional
clarifications about that, then just jump in the discussion on
ml-style, and I'll update it if need be.

As for Lauri example, yes, I was surprised as well that two groups
would be related through a PerformanceName AR (see previous message).

As for your case, though I'm not familiar at all with the artists, it
looks to me that:
- the AR to use between the *persons* and the *groups* should be a
"member of band" or "collaborated on" AR, and not a "PerfNameAR".
- the question about legally forced name changes was covered by Gecks
- I agree with that


2 cents...

- Olivier



More information about the MusicBrainz-users mailing list