[mb-users] Korn - Unidentifiables

[Age Bosma]

Simon Austin wrote:
> Anyone want to guess which of these DiscIDs for Korn's Untouchables are 
> real?
> 
> http://musicbrainz.org/show/release/details.html?releaseid=131264&show=times#discid
> 

Hehe, nice one.

At least one of the two id's ending with a track length of 9:26 belongs 
to the limited edition which has a 'Here to Stay (T Ray's Mix)' as a 
hidden track. I assume that only the first id 
(HzOTb_nK2Ak_K00gqM_vpU4M1js-) is valid in case of those two. The second 
one (ELi.LmdPJYohOVkOIZRBPnMSeQk-) looks to me to be a second generation 
homebrew disc. This release should be added separately if it has a 
different barcode then the one already present. Otherwise all other id's 
should be moved to a different release.

As for the other id's. There's not really a way of telling which is 
valid unless we have one confirmed based on the official disc. 
Personally I think the second one of the complete list is invalid 
(jrTA0rbGR5VJnb_kGyZkwwsZwRo-). The track durations from track 10 on 
differ significantly. The last one (cII.TCvjWuv2YYiCJ7bUvHnmESA-) looks 
like it belongs to the clean version of the release because of the 
different track order from 11 to 14 (based on track length).

You could say that that leaves only one valid one 
(EiYYS0kNO8w2ArIOcyceir2Srto-) but that one doesn't have a track length 
of 5:06. So...we need some confirmation from people who actually have 
the physical release.

The clean version release is either not present yet if Wikipedia is 
right about the last track not being a normal music file or it should 
have gone to the one already present with an additional track: 
http://musicbrainz.org/release/e7e040aa-579b-4a77-8659-37dfb09b5cef.html

Age


Source of reference: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Untouchables_(album)